Make this Eye of Toad Halloween Milkshake Recipe for all of your creepy little monsters! This Halloween dessert is made with cookies and cream ice cream, green coloring, whipped cream, red blood gel and topped with a gummy eyeball. This fun recipe is kid approved!
Our house is decorated in a pumpkin and witch theme. My daughter plans her costume for months before Halloween. And we go trick or treating and to a Halloween festival each year. We are serious about Halloween!
On a recent Target shopping trip we noticed these awesome gummy eyeballs. My daughter begged to get them. She didn’t really need to beg because I had already decided that these would be great in a Halloween dessert recipe.
My daughter came up with the name of this milkshake. Eye of Toad Halloween Milkshake is a perfect match to the bright green color and all of our witch decor.
Just be sure to keep your eye on your milkshake, otherwise some ghoul might steal it!
Here are a few more easy Halloween dessert recipes:
Here are some items you may need for this recipe: (affiliate links)
Ninja Blender (BL610)
Gummy Eyeballs (46 pcs)
- 2 Cups Cookies & Cream Ice Cream
- 1 Cup Milk
- 1/8 teaspoon Green Gel Food Coloring, (more or less to desired color)
- Red Sparkle Sugar Gel
- Whipped Cream
- Gummy Eyeballs
- Blend ice cream, milk and green coloring until smooth.
- Rim the inside of glasses with enough red gel that it begins to drip down.
- Carefully pour milkshake into glasses. Top with whipped cream, a dollop of red gel and a gummy eyeball.
This recipe makes 2 small servings or 1 large serving.
This post contains affiliate amazon links. Basically, I get a little kick back for sending you over to amazon . . . at no extra cost to you. Thanks for your support!