Bake a cake just like Grandma used to with this Vintage Buttermilk Vanilla Cake Recipe From Scratch. A delicate layer cake topped with homemade vanilla buttercream frosting!
I spend a lot of time thinking about how cooking and baking has evolved over the years. (I know that is a weird thing to ponder)
Would my Grandma approve of this generation of convenience cooking? She had 5 kids, of course she would take advantage of quick and easy recipes. So long as it still tasted good.
I’m positive my Grandma would still make her cakes from scratch. Does boxed cake mix taste good? Sure it does. But, do you know what tastes better?… This Buttermilk Vanilla Cake Recipe From Scratch.
I consciously kept this cake plain. First, I wanted the vanilla flavor to shine. Second, this cake can be enjoyed as is. Or dress it up however you want. Top with fresh fruit, edible flowers or sprinkles. This cake is the perfect starting point for your unique creation.
I wanted to highlight Rodelle Reserve Vanilla in a classic recipe for the modern day. Rodelle Reserve uses the best in historical techniques and modern technology to make the best vanilla available with the purest of ingredients and a vintage feel.
Sometimes it is worth a little extra time and effort to get the best. Rodelle Reserve was aged for 6 months in French Oak barrels to enrich the vanilla flavors and soften the harsher alcohol flavor that all extracts inherently have.
That is how my Grandma used to bake, with quality ingredients and lots of love. (of course)
This cake is timeless but will not take you all day to make!
Get your bottle of Rodelle Reserve now! Only 1600 bottle are available!
The imported Italian bottles were screen printed, and each bottle contains a gourmet Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla Bean. No one bottle will ever be the same!
So this one’s for Grandma. I think she would approve.
Buttermilk Vanilla Cake Recipe From Scratch
Ingredients
Cake
- 1/2 Cup Unsalted Butter, (softened)
- 1 Cup Sugar
- 2 Large Eggs
- 2 Cups Unbleached Cake Flour
- 3 teaspoons Baking Powder
- 1 teaspoon Sea Salt
- 1¼ Cup Buttermilk
- 2 teaspoons Rodelle Reserve Vanilla
Frosting
- 1½ Cups Unsalted Butter - softened
- 6 Cups Powdered Sugar
- 1 teaspoon Rodelle Reserve Vanilla
- 2 teaspoons Buttermilk
Instructions
Cake
- Preheat oven to 375°F
- Cream butter and sugar. Add eggs.
- Mix flour, baking powder and salt.
- Gradually add dry ingredients to wet while alternately adding buttermilk.
- Mix in vanilla.
- Divide batter between 2 (8") round cake pans that have been generously greased with butter or shortening.
- Bake 25 minutes or until edges are light golden brown.
- Allow cakes to cool in pans for 10 minutes. Transfer cakes to cooling racks. Allow to cool completely before frosting.
Frosting
- In a stand mixer fitted with the whisk attachment, whip the butter for 1 minute.
- Add the powdered sugar 1 cup at a time. Scrape the sides in between each addition. Mix for 30 seconds between each sugar addition.
- Add vanilla and buttermilk.
- Mix on medium/high speed for 4-5 minutes. Frosting will be light and creamy.
- Chill in the refrigerator for 30 minutes before frosting your cake. Whip once more before frosting cake.
Notes
Adapted from Eet Smakelijk
I am proud to be a brand ambassador partner with Rodelle. I receive free product as part of my brand ambassadorship. All opinions are 100% genuine.
91
Deborah says
February 25, 2018 atI made this cake it was delicious but the first set of cakes didn’t rise were likeFrisbees. I figured out my baking powder was expired. Went & bought new baking powder tried baking them again this time they did rise. I did have to add more buttermilk to the frosting 1 tablespoon at a time till I got the consistency that I liked. I will definitely make this again.
Nicole Harris says
February 27, 2018 atOh no! I hate when that happens. I’m glad the second go around worked out.
Michele says
February 28, 2018 atI made this cake and the batter was wonderful…however I put them in 8 inch pans and they hardly rose. My ingredients were all fresh including the baking powder. I read somewhere below in the comments that someone else had them only raise to an inch. I am an experienced baker – I am a bit disappointed. How high are these layers each supposed to be? Hopefully, it will taste fine but with 3 teaspoons baking powder I am a bit surprised.
Nicole Harris says
March 6, 2018 atOh No! Yes, it should rise more than that. It seems that for the most part people have success with this cake but every now and then the rise issue occurs. There are just so many variables in baking that I have not been able to pinpoint the cause :/
Anna says
March 2, 2018 atHello clariza…what kind of sugar have u added…granulated?powdered? Or castor…for the cake. And also do i have to add icing sugar for frosting..or is it still the granulated or powdered one that s been mentioned
Jennifer s says
March 2, 2018 atHello! Does the butter need to be at room temp for the cake? I was surprised it didn’t note in tv’s recipe that it should be softened.
Nicole Harris says
March 6, 2018 atYes, the butter should be softened (room temp) Thanks for commenting, I will go add that note to the recipe 🙂
Jen says
March 4, 2018 atWhat a wonderful cake recipe. I made it with my family’s caramel frosting and it was devine. I’ll definitely make it again! The recipe didn’t note to soften the butter for the cake, but I did. I assume it’s supposed to be softened?
Nicole Harris says
March 6, 2018 atAwesome! I bet it was great with caramel frosting 😀
mari says
March 25, 2018 athi, nicole i want to know if it is a 1 pound of cake, i need to make exactly 1 pound of cake and can i change the butter for oil?
Nicole Harris says
March 27, 2018 atI have not weighed the cake. I doubt it is exactly 1 Lb though. And no, I would stick to butter. Perhaps a google search would bring you to a recipe for a 1 Lb cake…maybe.
mari says
April 1, 2018 atthanks you so much for the reply!!!
Lynne says
April 7, 2018 atI want to make this cake for my twin boys’ birthday – can I add cocoa to make a chocolate version so each boy has his own cake? If so what is recommended and how much. THANKS!!
Nicole Harris says
April 10, 2018 atI have not attempted to make this chocolate. The addition of cocoa would increase the dry ingredients and therefore other dry ingredients would need to be adjusted. Wish I had a chocolate cake recipe to direct you to 🙂
Erica says
May 29, 2018 atHi Nicole I followed your recipe except for I used my favorite vanilla concentrate instead of the Rodelle vanilla. My cupcakes were delicious and rised perfectly. I filled the cupcake liners 3/4 full and the batter made 16 cupcakes. I baked them on the second to bottom lower rack in the oven for 18 minutes. I usually always leave my ingredients out for about an hour or so so they’ll come to room temp before making any cake recipe this helps with texture an overall a better product so I’m wondering if some of the comments where the cakes are not rising is due to having to cold of ingredients. Thank you fo sharing your recipe. I’m definitely keeping this one.
Nicole Harris says
June 3, 2018 atThanks for you tips. That is definitely a possibility 🙂
Maryam Hassan says
June 3, 2018 atHi Nicole, love this recipe. How do I cater this recipe for a three layered cake? (9 in diameter)
Nicole Harris says
June 3, 2018 atI’ve only made this as a two layer cake. You could double the recipe to have enough although there may be a little batter left over.
Jane says
June 8, 2018 atI made this cake this morning with some adjustments out of necessity. My daughter-in-law is gluten intolerant so I subbed Robin Hood all purpose GF flour. I’ve found through a lot of trial and error…mostly error lol…that gluten free flours tend to soak up a lot more moisture than “normal” flours. I added only 1 1/2 cups of flour instead, going more on the texture of the batter to get it right. It didn’t rise much but that was probably my own fault, while I was measuring ingredients the phone rang (freaking telemarketers) and couldn’t remember if I had added 2 or 3 teaspoons of baking powder. Since I’m going to use this cake for a strawberry cheese cake trifle the density will probably be a bit better for it.
Nicole Harris says
June 10, 2018 atGood to know the gf flour works with this cake . . . and yes, freaking telemarketers 😀
Andre Deverger says
June 12, 2018 atWhat happens if I whipped the buttermilk before adding to mix?
Nicole Harris says
June 14, 2018 atI have never whipped the buttermilk, so I’m not entirely sure.
Jerry says
June 12, 2018 atThe cake did not rise properly for me. Perhaps an inch high at the edges, with a badly cracked peak in the center. The texture was too dense and gooey. I was doubtful from the start because this recipe calls for baking powder. Most buttermilk recipes use baking soda instead. I tried again, this time substituting 1 1/2 teaspoons of baking soda for the baking powder. It rose more like a normal cake, but still not as high and light as I would expect.
Nicole Harris says
June 14, 2018 atThanks for the feedback and tip.
Jane says
July 7, 2018 atI would love to try this cake for my grandsons birthday cake but I wanted to make it as a sheet cake which is 12x16x2 do I have to change the receipe amounts any help would be greatly appreciated.
thanks, Jane
Nicole Harris says
July 16, 2018 atI have not made this as a sheet cake. There have been many commenters that have used a variety of different pans with success.
Mikaela says
August 14, 2018 atI made this cake for my moms bday and she loved it! i used an alcohol free vanilla from trader joes that tasted just fine. i also added orange zest and orange juice into the frosting and put fresh raspberries in the middle and top layer. It tasted fantastic, the cake was moist and the buttermilk (i think) added a good flavor (im not paul hollywood tho so idk)!
Nicole Harris says
August 16, 2018 atThat sounds tasty!
Judy says
September 10, 2018 atIs’n 6 cups of powered sugar alot for a 2 layer cake? Couldn’ I use maybe 4.5 or 5 cups. But if you think 6 cups want be too much frosting then I’ll use 6 because I do like a good bit of frosting. I just thought 6 cups would be WAY to much. Thanks.
Nicole Harris says
September 18, 2018 atYou can decrease it if you prefer 🙂
Judy says
September 10, 2018 atI also know if I lower the powered sugar in the frosting I will also lower the other ingredients in the frosting except the vanilla extract. I am going to use the new McCormick’s SMALL BATCH vanilla extract. Thanks.
Kat says
October 14, 2018 atThis recipe turned out great I used another reviewers suggestion for cupcakes and they came out tasting awesome with a really tender cake. I know we aren’t supposed to love box mix but box mix is flavorful and tender and not dry. This is even better. Only change I made was I added about a half teaspoon of almond extract. Thanks for this recipe truly delicious!
Nicole Harris says
October 15, 2018 atAwesome! I’m glad you loved them 🙂
Zee says
January 24, 2019 atIs this US measurements? I am in South Africa and would like to try this cake but but we use metrics and need to know if I should convert to metrics.
Nicole Harris says
January 29, 2019 atYes, US measurements 🙂
Curtis groll says
March 21, 2019 atI do not see the recipe, where is that located?
Nicole Harris says
March 21, 2019 atHi Curtis. Apologies, there was a major hack attack across the internet today. It caused havoc on many websites (including mine 😒) The issue has been corrected and the recipe is now back up. If you aren’t seeing it you may need to clear your browsing history. Sorry for the inconvenience.
curtis says
March 23, 2019 atoh no worries! thank you for the quick fix!
Cathy Gray says
May 26, 2019 atLove this recipe! ❤️ I make cakes for friends and family all of the time and this one is requested a lot. Thank you for sharing!
Nicole Harris says
May 28, 2019 atAwesome 🙂